When Fifty Shades of Grey (FSoG) first exploded onto the scene back in 2011, I was... skeptical. A Twilight fanfic that went viral? Billionaires with helicopters and "red rooms of pain"? The phrase "inner goddess" used unironically approximately seven thousand times? It seemed ridiculous. And yet, E.L. James's steamy trilogy about virginal college student Anastasia Steele and her relationship with damaged, controlling billionaire Christian Grey became a genuine cultural phenomenon, selling over 150 million copies worldwide and spawning a film franchise that made Jamie Dornan taking off his shirt into a legitimate news event.
Here's the thing, though: I get it now.
Not necessarily the appeal of Christian Grey himself—that man needs therapy, not a girlfriend—but the broader appeal of what Fifty Shades represented. Sexy billionaires sweeping ordinary women off their feet. Steam that could fog up your e-reader. Emotional intensity cranked up to eleven. The promise of being utterly consumed by someone's desire for you. (Even if that someone has serious boundary issues and a helicopter he named Charlie Tango, which, come on.)
So if you've already devoured the original trilogy, watched the movies, and you're looking for more books that capture that same intoxicating mix of wealth, steam, emotional baggage, and questionable relationship dynamics that somehow still manage to be compelling, I've got you covered. Some of these are better written than Fifty Shades. Some have healthier relationships. Some have worse relationships, if you can believe it. But they all have that addictive quality that made Christian and Ana's story so hard to put down, even when you knew you probably should.
If we're talking about books in the Fifty Shades universe, we absolutely have to start with Sylvia Day's Crossfire series, and Bared to You is where it all begins. The comparisons to E.L. James's work are inevitable—damaged billionaire? Check. Ordinary-ish woman drawn into his orbit? Check. Explicit scenes that'll make you glad you're reading on an e-reader in public? Oh, check. But here's where Day's series distinguishes itself: both Eva Tramell and Gideon Cross are working through serious trauma, not just the male lead. Gideon is a obscenely wealthy businessman (naturally) who becomes obsessed with Eva from the moment they meet, but Eva's not some wide-eyed innocent—she's got her own demons, her own therapy appointments, her own baggage. The power dynamic is more balanced, even if the sex scenes are just as scorching. Day's prose is tighter than James's, and while Gideon certainly has his controlling moments, the relationship feels slightly less like it should come with a domestic violence hotline number. Slightly. The Crossfire series spans five books, so if you fall for Eva and Gideon's angsty, steamy dynamic, you've got plenty of material to work with.
What if Christian Grey and Anastasia Steele had met in an office? And what if instead of being meek and submissive, Ana had been ambitious, driven, and fully capable of going toe-to-toe with her billionaire boss? That's essentially the premise of Beautiful Bastard, the first book in Christina Lauren's Beautiful series, which also started as Twilight fanfiction before being reworked into an original novel. (There was a lot of that going around in the early 2010s, apparently.) Chloe Mills is a hardworking MBA student interning for Bennett Ryan, the demanding, infuriating, and unfortunately hot heir to a media empire. They hate each other. They also can't keep their hands off each other. The banter is sharp, the steam is plentiful, and the "enemies who can't stop having sex in inappropriate places" trope is executed beautifully. It's Fifty Shades meets The Hating Game, and honestly? The writing duo of Christina Hobbs and Lauren Billings (who publish under the name Christina Lauren) are significantly better at crafting sentences than E.L. James. You won't encounter any "inner goddesses" here, thank god.
Speaking of The Hating Game—if you loved the power dynamics and office setting of Fifty Shades but wished it had more humor, better banter, and a male love interest who didn't require a safe word just to have a conversation, Sally Thorne's romcom sensation is essential reading. Lucy Hutton and Joshua Templeman are executive assistants at a publishing house, and they despise each other with the fire of a thousand suns. Or so they think. The truth is far more complicated, and as their hate-flirting evolves into something more, the tension becomes almost unbearable. Joshua is tall, intense, and controlled in a way that'll remind you of Christian Grey, but he's also funny, surprisingly vulnerable, and crucially, he respects Lucy's boundaries. The steam level isn't quite Fifty Shades territory—this is more romcom than erotica—but the build-up is so exquisitely crafted that when Lucy and Joshua finally get together, it's incredibly satisfying.
Emily McIntire's Never After series takes fairy tales and gives them dark, twisted, morally-gray makeovers with plenty of steam and angst. Twisted, a Peter Pan retelling, is particularly Fifty Shades-adjacent with its obsessive, dangerous male lead and the innocent woman who becomes entangled in his world. James Barrie is a casino owner with a drug empire and a serious revenge plot brewing. Wendy Michaels is a young woman trying to care for her brothers after their mother's death. When their paths cross, James becomes fixated on Wendy, pulling her into his dark world whether she wants to be there or not. The power imbalance is significant, the steam is explicit, and James is every bit as morally questionable as Christian Grey. If you're looking for that same "I know this man is bad for her but I can't stop reading" feeling, McIntire delivers.
L.J. Shen writes alpha heroes who make Christian Grey look like a sensitive poetry major, and Vicious is a prime example of her particular brand of angsty, bully romance. Baron "Vicious" Spencer is cruel, ruthless, and has spent years tormenting Emilia, the girl next door who's been in love with him since childhood. This is enemies-to-lovers cranked up to eleven, with a revenge plot, a marriage of convenience, and enough angst to fuel a dozen therapy sessions. The steam is scorching, the emotional intensity is overwhelming, and Vicious is absolutely a terrible person for most of the book. But if you're drawn to the dark, obsessive, all-consuming relationships that define Fifty Shades, Shen's work will scratch that itch. Fair warning: this is a bully romance, which means the "hero" does some genuinely awful things. It's not for everyone.
Okay, so. What if instead of a billionaire, the tortured, conflicted man with control issues was a Catholic priest? And what if the woman who wandered into his confessional wasn't looking for absolution but ended up finding something far more complicated? Sierra Simone's Priest is blasphemous, filthy, and somehow deeply emotional all at once. Father Tyler Bell is wrestling with his vows and his desires when Poppy Danforth stumbles into his church, and their connection is immediate, intense, and completely forbidden. The guilt, the angst, the "we absolutely cannot do this but we're going to anyway" energy—it's all very Fifty Shades, just with significantly more Catholic guilt and theological wrestling. The steam level is off the charts, and Simone's prose is genuinely beautiful in a way that elevates the story beyond simple erotica. If you want your steam with a side of emotional devastation and moral complexity, Priest delivers.
Another L.J. Shen entry, because when it comes to morally gray billionaires and intense, problematic relationships, she's basically the queen. The Kiss Thief features an arranged marriage between Francesca Rossi, the daughter of a mafia boss, and Senator Wolfe Keaton, a ruthless politician with his own agenda. Francesca is forced into this marriage, and Wolfe is cold, distant, and determined to make her miserable. It's dark, it's angsty, and the power imbalance is significant. But as the story unfolds, layers are peeled back, and what emerges is a complicated, intense love story that'll have you ugly crying by the end. The steam is plentiful, the emotional stakes are sky-high, and Wolfe is exactly the kind of damaged, controlling man that Fifty Shades fans tend to love (or love to hate).
Here's where things get interesting, and potentially uncomfortable. Lilah Pace's Asking For It features a heroine, Vivienne, who has rape fantasies and is looking for a partner who can help her safely explore that kink. She meets Jonah, and together they negotiate boundaries and build trust while engaging in consensual non-consent scenes. This is significantly more thoughtful and well-executed than Fifty Shades' fumbling attempts at BDSM representation. Pace (a pseudonym for romance author Claudia Gray) actually does the research, portrays negotiation and consent properly, and creates characters who communicate about their desires and boundaries. If you were drawn to the BDSM elements of Fifty Shades but frustrated by how poorly it was portrayed, Asking For It is a much better, more responsible exploration of kink. The steam is explicit, the emotional connection is genuine, and the relationship is actually healthy, despite the taboo nature of the fantasy being explored.
Penelope Douglas's Devil's Night series is dark romance at its finest (or most depraved, depending on your perspective). Corrupt introduces us to Erika Fane and Michael Crist, whose history is complicated, painful, and deeply messed up. Michael and his friends tormented Erika in high school, and now, years later, he's back in her life and determined to make her pay for perceived sins. This is bully romance, dark romance, and revenge romance all rolled into one deeply problematic package. The steam is intense, the relationship is toxic, and Michael is absolutely terrible for most of the book. But if you're drawn to the obsessive, all-consuming, "this is definitely unhealthy but I can't look away" relationships that Fifty Shades pioneered in mainstream fiction, Douglas delivers that in spades. The series gets progressively darker with each book, so consider yourself warned.
Kresley Cole is known for her paranormal romance, but The Professional is a contemporary romance about Aleksandr "The Siberian" Sevastyan, a ruthless enforcer for the Russian mob who becomes obsessed with Natalie Porter, an innocent college student who happens to be the secret daughter of a powerful Russian politician. When Aleksandr kidnaps Natalie to bring her to her father, their forced proximity leads to an intense, steamy relationship complicated by lies, danger, and Aleksandr's dark past. He's controlling, possessive, and morally gray in all the ways Christian Grey is, but with added Russian mob drama. The steam is explicit, the emotional intensity is high, and Natalie's journey from innocent student to woman navigating a dangerous new world mirrors Ana's trajectory in Fifty Shades. Plus, Cole's writing is sharp and engaging, making this an easy binge-read.
If you thought Christian Grey was controlling, meet Anthony Rawlings. Consequences is dark romance taken to its absolute extreme, featuring an incredibly wealthy, powerful man who kidnaps a young woman and holds her captive, gradually breaking down her resistance through psychological manipulation and abuse. This is not a love story in any traditional sense—it's Stockholm syndrome: the novel. Anthony is a monster, and the relationship is deeply, deeply unhealthy. So why include it on this list? Because it captures the same "powerful man completely consuming a woman's life" dynamic that Fifty Shades flirts with but never fully commits to. Romig takes that premise to its darkest possible conclusion. This is not for everyone. In fact, it's probably not for most people. But if you're looking for something that makes Fifty Shades look tame by comparison, Consequences will do exactly that. Read with caution.
Sometimes you don't want subversion or complexity—you just want the billionaire fantasy delivered straight, no chaser. The Scandals of the Bad Boy Billionaires series by Ivy Layne is exactly that. The Ruthless Billionaire features Jackson Winters, a wealthy businessman with a dark past, and Emilia Winters, the woman he's been in love with for years but pushed away. When circumstances force them together, the passion that never really died comes roaring back. It's got the wealth, the angst, the steam, and the "I'm not good enough for you" hero that Fifty Shades fans love. The writing is solid, the characters are engaging, and while it's not reinventing the wheel, it's a satisfying, steamy read that delivers exactly what it promises.
Here's what I've learned after reading dozens of books like Fifty Shades of Grey: the appeal isn't really about Christian Grey specifically, or even the BDSM elements that got so much attention. It's about the fantasy of being utterly consumed by someone's desire. Of being the center of someone's universe. Of a powerful man who could have anyone but chooses you, specifically you, and will move heaven and earth to keep you.
Is it realistic? Absolutely not.
Is it healthy? Often, no.
But is it a compelling fantasy that millions of readers connect with? Clearly.
The books on this list all tap into that same vein, whether through billionaire CEOs, mob enforcers, priests wrestling with their vows, or tortured bad boys with tragic pasts. Some handle the premise better than others. Some have healthier relationships. Some have worse relationships, if you can believe it. But they all understand what made Fifty Shades so addictive, and they deliver it in their own unique ways.
So grab your e-reader, find a comfortable spot, and prepare to be swept away by morally questionable men with jawlines that could cut glass and bank accounts that could buy small countries. Your inner goddess (or whatever you want to call it) will thank you.
Some of the links above are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, CritiReads may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support our work!