Look, I get it. You finished Twilight and immediately devoured the rest of Stephenie Meyer's saga in approximately 72 hours. You've watched the movies. Multiple times. You know every meme. And now you're sitting there, staring at your bookshelf, wondering what could possibly fill that vampire-shaped hole in your chest.
I've been there. We've all been there.
The thing about Twilight is that it's not just about vampires. It's about yearning. It's about that all-consuming, can't-eat-can't-sleep kind of love that makes you feel like you're going to combust if you're not near the person you're obsessed with. It's about danger and desire wrapped up in a pretty supernatural package. And honestly? There are so many books out there that capture that same addictive energy Meyer perfected, whether they involve bloodsuckers, werewolves, faeries, or just regular humans with extremely intense feelings.
So I've rounded up books that'll scratch that Twilight itch. Some have vampires. Some don't. But all of them have romance that'll make your stomach flip, supernatural drama that'll keep you up past your bedtime, and that delicious tension between danger and desire that made Bella and Edward's relationship so magnetic.
If you loved the forbidden romance aspect of Twilight—you know, the whole "he could literally kill me but I'm wildly attracted to him anyway" thing—then Sarah J. Maas is about to become your new obsession. Her ACOTAR series starts when Feyre, a human huntress, kills a wolf in the woods and gets dragged to the faerie realm as punishment by Tamlin, a powerful High Fae lord. What begins as captivity slowly transforms into something else entirely. Something heated. The slow burn is exquisite. The world-building is lush and detailed. And the series just keeps getting better as it goes on, with plot twists that'll have you screaming into your pillow at 2 AM. Fair warning: the first book is YA-adjacent, but by book two, things get decidedly more adult. The fandom is massive. The fan art is everywhere. And once you start, good luck putting it down.
Remember how Twilight made you fall in love with the idea of star-crossed supernatural romance? Stiefvater's Wolves of Mercy Falls series does the same thing, but with werewolves. Grace has been obsessed with the wolves in the woods behind her house ever since they saved her life as a child. Specifically, she's been obsessed with one wolf with unusual yellow eyes. When a boy named Sam appears in her life with those same yellow eyes, Grace realizes the wolves aren't what they seem. The catch? Sam can only be human during the warm months. As winter approaches, their time together is running out. Stiefvater's prose is gorgeous and lyrical. The atmosphere is melancholy and romantic. And the central relationship has that same intense, all-consuming quality that made Bella and Edward so compelling. Plus: actual werewolves who are wolves, not just guys who turn into giant dogs. (Looking at you, Jacob.)
If Edward Cullen's whole mysterious, dangerous, "I shouldn't be near you but I can't stay away" vibe really worked for you, then you need to meet Patch. He's a fallen angel. He sits next to Nora in biology class. (Sound familiar?) He's infuriating and secretive and possibly dangerous, but Nora can't stop thinking about him. The series has that same addictive quality as Twilight, with supernatural mythology, a brooding love interest who may or may not be good for the protagonist, and enough tension to make your teeth hurt. It's dramatic. It's swoony. And yes, there's a leather jacket involved. The paranormal romance community went feral for this series when it came out, and honestly? I understand why.
Here's something different: Beautiful Creatures flips the Twilight script by putting the supernatural element on the girl instead of the guy. Ethan is a regular human boy stuck in a small Southern town, desperate to escape. Lena is the mysterious new girl with strange powers and a curse hanging over her head. On her sixteenth birthday, she'll be claimed by either the light or the dark, and there's nothing she can do to stop it. The romance is intense and fatalistic in that delicious Twilight way. The Southern Gothic atmosphere is thick enough to cut with a knife. And the whole series has this dreamy, magical quality that makes you want to move to a small town full of secrets. (Even though that's probably a terrible idea.)
Okay, yes, more vampires. But hear me out. Rose Hathaway is training to be a guardian—basically a vampire bodyguard—for her best friend Lissa, a Moroi vampire princess. The series has all the vampire politics and supernatural drama you could want, plus a romance with Dimitri, Rose's older, incredibly hot mentor, that is chef's kiss. The forbidden nature of their relationship (student/teacher, guardian/charge) creates that same kind of delicious tension that Bella and Edward had. The action is fantastic. The world-building is detailed and fascinating. And Rose is a much more active protagonist than Bella, which is refreshing. If you wanted Bella to occasionally kick some ass, you'll love Rose.
Aislinn can see faeries. She's always been able to see them. And she knows the rules: don't let them know you can see them, don't interact with them, don't ever draw their attention. Unfortunately, Keenan, the Summer King, has noticed her, and he's convinced she's the girl who can break his curse. The series is dark and dangerous, with faerie politics, a love triangle that'll tear you apart, and that same sense of inevitability that made Twilight so addictive. Plus, the urban fantasy setting—modern world but with faeries everywhere—is incredibly atmospheric.
Lucinda Price is sent to Sword & Cross, a reform school for troubled teens, after a mysterious incident. There she meets Daniel, a gorgeous guy who seems to hate her on sight. Except... she's sure she knows him from somewhere. The mystery at the heart of Fallen—why does Luce feel this inexplicable connection to Daniel?—unfolds slowly, with past lives, fallen angels, and an epic, centuries-spanning romance. It's got that same "we're meant to be together across time and space" energy that Twilight trades in. The atmosphere is moody and Gothic. And the romantic angst is premium.
Calla is an alpha werewolf, destined to marry Ren and lead their pack together. It's all planned out. Except then she saves a human boy named Shay, and suddenly everything she thought she knew about her world starts to unravel. The love triangle is genuinely compelling. The werewolf mythology is detailed and interesting. And there's a whole conspiracy plot involving magic and power that gives the series depth beyond just the romance. If you liked the werewolf pack dynamics in Twilight but wished there was more of it, Nightshade delivers.
Bianca is starting at Evernight Academy, a boarding school for, well, let's just say it's very exclusive. She feels out of place among the beautiful, sophisticated students. Then she meets Lucas, who seems to be the only other person who doesn't quite fit in. Of course, there's more going on at Evernight than meets the eye. Gray's series has great twists, a genuinely surprising take on vampire mythology, and a romance that evolves in interesting ways as the books progress. The boarding school setting gives it a slightly different flavor than Twilight, but the central romance has that same intensity.
Clary thought she was a normal girl. Then she witnessed a murder in a club that no one else could see, and her entire world changed. Suddenly she's thrown into the world of Shadowhunters—warriors who hunt demons—and discovers her mother has been keeping massive secrets. The series has everything: hot guys with mysterious pasts, forbidden romance, found family, angels and demons, and enough plot twists to keep you guessing. Jace, the main love interest, has that same dangerous, damaged, "I'm not good for you" energy as Edward. The series is long. The world is huge. And once you start, you won't want to stop.
What if vampires were actually fallen angels? And what if they were all hiding in plain sight among Manhattan's elite? De la Cruz's series takes vampire mythology in a fascinating direction, following Schuyler Van Alen as she discovers she's part of an ancient vampire bloodline. There's reincarnation, past lives, soulmates across centuries, and a mystery that spans the entire series. The New York setting gives it a glamorous, sophisticated vibe. The romance is epic and complicated. And the vampire lore is genuinely original.
Katy moves to West Virginia and immediately clashes with her impossibly hot, impossibly rude neighbor Daemon. He's arrogant. He's infuriating. And he's definitely hiding something. Turns out Daemon and his sister are aliens, and by getting close to Katy, Daemon has accidentally marked her, making her visible to their enemies. The banter between Katy and Daemon is fantastic. The romance is steamy. And the series has great action and mythology. If you liked the "he's dangerous but I can't stay away" dynamic of Twilight, you'll love this.
Karou is an art student in Prague with blue hair and a very unusual life—she runs errands for Brimstone, a monster who collects teeth through a door that leads to anywhere in the world. When mysterious handprints start appearing on doorways around the world and a seraph named Akiva enters her life, Karou starts uncovering the truth about who she really is. Taylor's writing is absolutely gorgeous. The world-building is lush and inventive. And the romance is devastating in the best possible way. This series is darker and more literary than Twilight, but it has that same sense of an epic, fated love story.
If you're ready to age up a bit from YA, Adams' Soulbound series offers adult fantasy romance with elves, magical bonds, and that same sense of destined love that Twilight trades in. Arlyn is pulled into the world of the Sidhe when she discovers she's the daughter of an elven prince. Lyr is dealing with his own complicated past. When they meet, there's an instant connection that might be magical or might be something deeper. The romance is steamy. The fantasy world is detailed. And there's actual adult communication happening, which is refreshing.
Look, I know nothing will ever be exactly like reading Twilight for the first time. That's impossible. But these books capture different elements of what made Meyer's series so addictive. Some have the supernatural danger. Some have the all-consuming romance. Some have both. What they all have is that ability to make you forget you're reading words on a page and instead feel like you're falling into another world entirely.
So grab a few of these. Clear your schedule. Maybe stock up on snacks. Because once you start, you're going to be up way past your bedtime, muttering "just one more chapter" for the fifth time in a row.
Trust me. I've been there.
Some of the links above are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, CritiReads may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support our work!